Paul & Eddie, two co-stars in the musical "e; Adam & Steve Just the Way God Made Em, "e; are each pondering major life decisions: Paul wants to give up dating & have no-strings sex; Eddies considering coming out to his super-religious parents. While at first these changes bring major disasters (Eddies parents panic at the news, Paul ruins a one-night stand), a great night of satire, costumes, singing, & dancing gives everyone the confidence to just be themselves.