For 40 years a battle has been waged over Vatican II between conservatives & liberals between those who want to go back to the sources" & those who champion "the spirit of the council." Benedict XVI is clearly one of those who started out as a liberal only to end up in the conservative camp. " Vatican II: Did Anything Happen?" is clearly on the side of those who think something unprecedented happened that a genie was let out of the bottle that will never be stuffed back. Comprised mainly of a collection of articles mostly but not all from Theological Studies that are without qualification some of the best analysis of the council ever written this book is a long overdue look at one of the most controversial & revolutionary chapters in the history of the Catholic Church."