Harper's Bazaar Beauty Hot 100 2012 – Best Liquid Liners: "" Whether you use a gel, ink pen or felt-tip liner, these two always come out on top with our testers for ease, longevity & intensity."" The smude-tip smoky eye, for up to 16 hours longwear! A creamy, smudge-tip eyeliner pencil perfect for creating a smokey eye look. The built-in sharpener means you can also draw a precise, even line. The formula gives lasting wear for up to 16 hours, without fading! L' Oréal Paris Infallible Retractable Eyeliner: a liner that lasts the day! The long-lasting formula gives intense colour for up to 16 hours without fading. Super easy to apply & can be removed with a make-up cleanser.