Seth excitedly introduces a skeptical Ryan to Chrismukkah, a Cohen family tradition that resulted from Kirsten being Christian & Sandy being Jewish. As everyone prepares for a huge holiday party organized by Julie (recurring guest star MELINDA CLARKE), Seth continues attempting to juggle Anna (recurring guest star SAMAIRE ARMSTRONG) & Summer (recurring guest star RACHEL BILSON), both of whom want to date him exclusively. Meanwhile, on opposing sides of a lawsuit, Sandy & Kirsten dread working through the holiday season, but Kirsten learns something about her father that could change everything. & Ryan & Marissa's shopping trip leads to trouble--and the beginning of even bigger problems for Marissa.