Mary & Marshall's first case together in 2003 is revisited after an amorous couple in Baltimore witnesses the brutal killings of the boyfriend's family. Marshall & a reluctant Mary must transport Henry Doer (Josh Cooke) & Claudia Tobin (Jeannine Kaspar) across the country to the safe haven of Albuquerque. Flash-forward to 2010: Mary & Marshall are rehashing this first case when the couple
- now on the road to romantic ruin
- jeopardises their identities when Henry comes to realise that the romance has died. There's also a new face at Wit Sec headquarters. The newly appointed U.S. Marshall in town Allison Pearson (Allison Janney), doesn't make a very good first impression with Mary. Mary's sister, Brandi (Nichole Hiltz), is struggling to have her tuition check refunded. & Peter even offers to help her financially, but Brandi has plans of her own.